⚠️ De site vereist een werkende browser met JavaScript & DOM-ondersteuning voor het beste resultaat.

How Linux developers defeated the new OS age-verification laws

#1 Lisk91
The coordinated effort worked. When lawmakers finalized Colorado SB26-051, they added Section 6-30-105(e) to the text. This specific clause waives compliance for operating systems and applications distributed under licenses that allow copying, modifying, and redistributing without platform-imposed technical restrictions.
Why the Section 6-30-105(e) Exemption Protects Decentralized Tech

This exemption establishes a formal legislative precedent for the tech industry. It legally shields free and open-source operating systems from hardware-level age attestation laws that closed ecosystems like iOS and Windows will soon have to follow.

#2 GorGor
is there a similar contingency in the California law?
#3 yesman
It's unenforceable on Linux. A Linux user can simply remove or modify any code running on their machine. Fedora, Debian, and Arch can't make a user verify their age any more than they can force you to use Gnome. It's kinda the whole point of FOSS. 👍
#4 BartyDeCanter
Not yet, but I’ve spoken with Wicks staffers responsible for writing the bill. They are very aware of the open source issues and working on getting changes implemented during the current legislative session.
#5 Lost_My_Mind
There is a very easy way to force linux users to enforce this. However, I won't give it away here, because as far as I can tell the current law makers are clueless.

And I don't want to give them clues. 😂
#6 bhamlin
And that's the whole point of the amendment to that law. Their congress critters were enlightened on the futility of such an endeavor. Next is California.
#7 OwOarchist
You know ... now that open source is officially a legal loophole, I could see this making it more popular.

New reason to use Linux: You're 13 and you want to look at boobs on the internet, but other operating systems won't let you.
#8 pennomi
There isn’t an easy way. There may be a way to enforce it when you connect to a remote site, but that requires the remote computer to implement it, not you.
#9 potatoguy
I'm already seeing that in a year or two, we're getting blocked on websites or electron applications because of age verification just like in android with Google Play Services. Like use age verification software or get blocked for 99% the internet.

They don't even need to turn it into law.
#10 floofloof
From the linked System76 blog:

New York’s proposed Senate Bill S8102A requires adults to prove they’re adults to use a computer, exercise bike, smart watch, or car if the device is internet enabled with app ecosystems. The bill explicitly forbids self-reporting and leaves the allowed methods to regulations written by the Attorney General. Practical methods for a bill of such extreme breadth would require, in many instances, providing private information to a third-party just to use a computer at all. Privacy disappears.


That's appalling, and NY won't be the only government trying it. This is going to be one of those battles we need to fight again and again. 👍
#11 SeeMarkFly
Our current law makers are still debating if freeing the slaves was a good idea. That's how far behind they are.
#12 CosmicTurtle0
I'm going to argue that you share it because one thing you can count on is very determined nerds to defeat it.

Every time legislators tried to enforce some sort of dystopian thing, developers saw it as damage and routed around it.
#13 MalReynolds
You're not wrong, security through obscurity eventually fails. In this case however, time counts, the longer it can be cut off, the more chance of some sanity returning, of backlash building politically. The time to route around is after a law is made, preferably as flawed a law as possible.
#14 MalReynolds
I must admit pessimism here, once this crap has the 99% (OK 95% or less for non-phones) accepting it, they'll come for linux (or the ISPs). When they came for the gays I didn't speak out... It's the thin end of the wedge (OK, extremely thick end). Colorado is not the world. The laws will be flawed, but continue to be amended, perfected, worldwide, because politicians as a class hate free speech, and anonymity protects free speech. The technically able will keep finding loopholes, but the vast majority will be left behind.

Probably there will be an exception made for corporations, after all, they have more need for privacy than the populace. /s 🙂
#15 MisterD
Too bad this is moot. Google wants to deploy QR codes to prove you are human and not AI. The QR code is for your phone to prove you are real. Oops, your phone has a uuid and phone number and there goes your privacy.

🔗 Related topics

spacer
Shoutbox 0
💬 Shoutbox
Mayumi: Very nice, daddy!
webmastahh: From now on, this website is expanding to an international audience!! 🙂😄
Webmastahhh: Joined a random match in krunker, got destroyed instantly, left
Webmastahhh: “just one match”... 3 hours later. 🙁
Webmastahhh: So I’ve got Paralives, new James Bond, No Man’s Sky and Final Fantasy XIV on my list…What should I start with first?
Webmastahhh: Stay cool, stay hydrated, and keep stacking those wins. Whether you're chilling in the shade or battling online, today is a perfect day to game! ️Who's playing right now?
beep: PlayStation had decided that you can't play your purchased games offline and Xbox is deep in it's enshittification. Quick somebody call an ambulance!
The Picard Maneuver: People are saying not enough eyes either. Sad.
7101334: What happened to good destruction-physics focused games?
CaptainBasculin: A really creative way to ask getting into a playtest
ragingHungryPanda: My friend said this yesterday, so I made it a meme
cannedtuna: Just got my first Steam Machine and I’m excited to try it out. Just love that clear purple casing.
The Picard Maneuver: The horror!
The Picard Maneuver: Problem solved
Steelkrill Studio: I’m a solo developer creating a detective horror game where you search for victims by a boat, inspired by the real-life Island of the Dolls in Mexico. I’d really appreciate any feedback!
cannedtuna: The bestest boy will always be by your side. ALWAYS.
Paradachshund: With as few spoilers as possible, how early access is subnautica 2?
QuentinCallaghan: The Original Doom Soundtrack Is Officially In The Library Of Congress
cannedtuna: Publisher CEO for Subnautica asked ChatGPT how to avoid paying out bonuses
webmastahh: FINAL FANTASY VII REBIRTH is now available on Nintendo Switch™ 2, Xbox Series X|S and Xbox on PC as part of Xbox Play Anywhere.
RandyEmons: hello world

250 left
smile grin sad wink tongue out surprised confused laughing XD heart
🏠 Start 👾 News 💾 Downloads 💬 Community Profile Profile