⚠️ De site vereist een werkende browser met JavaScript & DOM-ondersteuning voor het beste resultaat.

What do github stars even mean?

#1 nikolasdimi
Went through a competitor's stargazers. Most of them aren't real.

I open sourced an API IDE this year. Same space as Postman, Insomnia and the rest, but at the same time nothing like them: everything is plain text files in your repo, offline, no account etc.

One of the first things I thought and cared about in the early days was of course downloads and installs. And secondarily, it was stars.

And yeah, some of the competitors (that are also open source) have star counts I envied.

And we didnt do bad, we got 1000 stars relatively easily, with the first launches, rollouts. Developers seem to love what we are doing (the fact that we are not trying to clone Postman and make sth unique instead).

Recently I did the grubby founder thing and opened a competitor's stargazers list (one of the big ones). Partly curiosity, partly hoping to find some users or emails to reach out to. Not proud of it but ok, I was just curious to see who are the users.

Except there were almost no people in there.

Accounts a few months old. Zero repos or one fork. No activity. Multiple usernames like 4145243@ere.com. Public emails that were pure gibberish. Pages and pages of this.

How did this happen? : either they bought stars , or bot farms starred them to make the bots themselves look legit. I

In the beginning I was looking up to the stars but it seems they are as about as real as Instagram followers in 2015.

The only thing my outreach scheme found: the audience I was envying might not exist.

p.s. here is the repo of my tool , in case you wanna have a look.

🔗https://github.com/VoidenHQ/voiden (yeah we have 1272 stars right now and they are all actual devs 🙂


😂
#2 ExtremeDullard
Stars are to Github what reviews are to Amazon.

Also, what's the point of stars? Do you need confirmation to know your code is appreciated? The real metric for popularity is issues opened per week. Stars are just gamification - same as comment scores here. 🔥
#3 Canuck
Stars have real impact, some tools will give you free access to them if you have past a certain threshold of stars
#4 nikolasdimi
yeah probably for companies that look for funding?
#5 nikolasdimi
yes, the only thing I am thinking is that investors might be interested in stars as a way to measure adoption 🔥
#6 ultimate_worrier
OP develops software by popularity contest:
- an idea born straight from delusion: “hey Claude, build me a version of curl that can be used by vibecoding tech bros that don’t understand anything except JavaScript and do everything in unstructured, plain text files when yaml or another type of file would have been far superior”
- replicates functionality of other software
- cares more about stars than the tech
- written in JavaScript
- targets Electron (with a long discussion about why… in the end, decided by another popularity contest)
- caters to LLM’s
- OP is more concerned with selling their idea than implementing it
- obviously vibe-coded to the extent that the LLM decided the stack

I guess we should be thankful it has a proper license. I personally won’t be touching this techbro slopfest with a ten foot pole.

Perhaps I’ll check it out if you rewrite it in a proper language like Rust!? /s

Afbeelding 😆
#7 ExtremeDullard
Ah okay, I wasn't aware. I only use the non-proprietary bits of GitHub - i.e. git - so I essentially waste Microsoft's resources to host my things and they have no surveillance data to monetize to show for it.

🔗 Related topics

spacer
Shoutbox 0
💬 Shoutbox
webmastahh: The classic sci-fi strategy game Nexus: The Jupiter Incident is currently FREE during GOG's Summer Sale. Have you ever played it? 🚀 https://mastanet.com/287ff1 #GOG #Free #GamingDeals #drmfree #Gaming
webmastahh: 🎤 League of Legends' virtual K-pop group K/DA is rumored to return in 2026! 👀 Leaks suggest new music and brand-new in-game skins could be on the way. Would you be excited to see them return? #LeagueOfLegends #Kpop #GamingNews #Gaming
webmastahh: 🎮 BREAKING: Nintendo Switch 2 rumors just got hotter 🔥 Final Fantasy XV could be on the way 👀 If true, this is HUGE for console gaming in 2026. Next-gen hype is real ⚡ #Nintendo #Switch2 #FinalFantasyXV #GamingNews #NextGen #Hype #Console
webmastahh: 🔥 Cyberpunk 2077 hits 40 MILLION copies sold! From a rocky launch to a full comeback story 💥 Updates, Phantom Liberty & 2.0 turned it into a true modern RPG classic. Night City keeps winning. #Cyberpunk2077 #Gaming #CDPR
webmastahh: Mastanet 🎮 What makes it unique? Mastahhh Gaming Network brings gaming websites together on one platform with live news feeds ⚡ Everything in one place 👉 https://mastanet.com/ #Gaming #News #GameNews #GamingCommunity
webmastahh: $80 for digital games doesn’t make sense anymore 💸 We removed physical costs… but not the price. Gaming pricing feels stuck in a world that doesn’t exist anymore 🎮🤔 What are we actually paying for? #ps5 #xbox #gaming #playstation #nintendo #f
webmastahh: 💿 Sony says devs can still order disc games after 2027 (if released before cutoff). Xbox already uses it to push Halo discs 👀 Physical vs digital debate just got real again. #Gaming #News #PS5 #Xbox
webmastahh: Black Ops 6 is leaving the Call of Duty HQ app this week 💀 That means it won’t launch through COD’s main hub anymore, but as a separate game. #CallOfDuty #BlackOps6 #Gaming
webmastahh: Pokémon cards are so heavily resold that Nintendo may add ID checks to stop scalpers 💀 basically people buying cards just to flip them for profit. #Pokemon #Nintendo #Gaming
webmastahh: 💿 No discs? No thanks. If the reports about PlayStation's 2028 plans are true, gaming loses a big part of what made collecting games special. #PlayStation #Gaming
webmastahh: 💿 Love physical PlayStation games? Sign the petition 👇 https://mastanet.com/f8017a #PlayStation #Gaming
webmastahh: 💿 Over 120,000 people have already signed the "Don't Kill The Disc" petition to preserve physical games. Are physical games worth saving, or is an all-digital future inevitable? 🤔 #PlayStation #PS6 #Gaming
webmastahh: 🕹️ New PlayStation accessories are coming! FlexStrike wireless fight stick, 27” Gaming Monitor & Pulse Elevate speakers are expanding the PS5 setup 🎮🔥 #PlayStation #PS5 #Gaming
webmastahh: 🎮 FREE on GOG! Claim Silence before it's gone. A beautiful story-driven adventure with stunning hand-painted visuals. Keep it forever once claimed! ⏳ Ends in 3 days. https://www.gog.com/en/game/silence #FreeGame #GOG #PCGaming #Gaming #GameDeals
webmastahh: 👀 Pokémon Winds and Waves could introduce 300 new Pokémon?! Sounds insane… but don't get too excited yet 😅 The game isn't even out until 2027. 🌊⚡ #Pokemon #gaming #winds #waves

250 left
🏠 Start 👾 News 💾 Downloads 💬 Community Profile Profile